However, the Song: Valley of the Dolls

I woke up this morning with an earworm.

Not an unpleasant one, fortunately. In fact, it was a song I probably hadn’t consciously thought about in decades: Dionne Warwick singing “(Theme from) Valley of the Dolls.”

Which sent me down a rabbit hole.

I was ten years old when Jacqueline Susann’s Valley of the Dolls was published in 1966, and eleven when the movie arrived the following year. I remember my parents having the book lying around the house.

I was more interested in Star Trek.

This was probably just as well.

Valley of the Dolls was not exactly children’s literature. The “dolls” of the title are pills—uppers, downers, sleeping pills and various other pharmaceuticals swallowed by three women trying to survive careers, relationships, ambition and celebrity in the entertainment business.

Susann herself had spent years around show business as an actress and television personality before turning to novels, and Valley of the Dolls was her great breakthrough. Twentieth Century-Fox thought enough of the project to buy the film rights in October 1965, before the novel was even published, for more than $100,000; later reports put the figure closer to $200,000.

That turned out to be a pretty good bet.

The book reached number one on the New York Times bestseller list in May 1966 and stayed there for 28 consecutive weeks. Altogether it spent 65 weeks on the list. By the time Susann died in 1974, more than 17 million copies had reportedly been sold.

So let us establish something right at the beginning:

Jacqueline Susann did not need my approval.

Nor, apparently, did she need the approval of literary critics.

I finally tried reading Valley of the Dolls many years later. I made it about halfway through before thinking:

Dear God, who told Jacqueline Susann she could write?!

Then I looked up the contemporary reviews and discovered that a great many professional critics had already asked essentially the same question.

Gloria Steinem opened one review with this delightful observation:

“For the reader who has put away comic books but isn’t ready for editorials in The Daily News…”

…Valley of the Dolls might fill the gap.

Time called the novel a “highly effective sedative, a living doll.”

And Gore Vidal supplied the line that may have outlived almost every other review:

“She doesn’t write, she types.”

Ouch.

Even Nora Ephron, who admitted that she couldn’t put the book down, compared the experience to reading a “very, very long, absolutely delicious gossip column.”

That may actually be closer to explaining the phenomenon than the insults do.

Susann might not have written elegant prose, but she knew how to make people keep turning pages. She wrote about sex, pills, ambition, celebrity, betrayal and women being chewed up by the machinery of show business. Readers gobbled it up.

Susann’s own response to literary criticism was refreshingly uncomplicated. She said she wrote for the public rather than for critics. And the public responded by purchasing the book in numbers most writers can only hallucinate about.

As the saying goes, it’s difficult to argue with success.

I remember deciding, when I eventually encountered the book, that I would never write soap opera simply because soap opera might sell books.

I still feel that way.

But I also have to acknowledge the scoreboard.

Jacqueline Susann: millions upon millions of copies.

Andrea: considerably fewer.

Point to Susann.

And Then Hollywood Got Hold of It

The movie adaptation opened in December 1967, directed by Mark Robson and starring Barbara Parkins, Patty Duke and Sharon Tate, with Susan Hayward as the formidable Broadway star Helen Lawson.

The production itself had enough drama to qualify as another Jacqueline Susann novel.

Judy Garland was originally cast as Helen Lawson and had even recorded material for the film before leaving the production. Susan Hayward replaced her and reportedly completed her scenes in four days.

The resulting film was not exactly embraced by critics, either. Nevertheless, audiences came. By March 1969, Valley of the Dolls had grossed about $20 million and had become Fox’s highest-earning film of 1968.

Once again:

The critics said, This is a celluloid atrocity.

The public said, Shut up and take my money.

And in the years since, the movie has achieved something perhaps even stranger than respectability: it has become a camp classic. People don’t necessarily watch Valley of the Dolls despite its excesses anymore.

They watch it for them.

However, the Song

Yes.

The song.

Because somewhere inside this monument to pills, melodrama, celebrity, bad life decisions and critically abused prose is something genuinely beautiful.

André Previn wrote the music and Dory Previn the lyrics for “(Theme from) Valley of the Dolls.” Dionne Warwick recorded it, and her version reached number two on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1968.

The song bears almost no resemblance to the lurid reputation of the book.

It is quiet.

Melancholy.

Almost dreamlike.

The lyrics aren’t really about scandal or celebrity. They’re about disorientation—the unsettling realization that you have followed some road without quite knowing how you got there, and the even more unsettling question of whether you can find your way back.

And then there is Dionne Warwick’s voice.

There are singers who demonstrate what a voice can do, and there are singers who make you forget that you’re listening to somebody demonstrate anything.

Warwick does the latter.

She doesn’t attack the song. She doesn’t wring it dry trying to prove how sad it is. She simply lets that extraordinary voice float over the melody, controlled and almost fragile, while the sadness accumulates underneath it.

I think that’s why the song survives independently of the movie.

You don’t need to know who Anne Welles or Neely O’Hara are. You don’t need to know that “dolls” are pills. You don’t need to have read Jacqueline Susann or watched Patty Duke chew great chunks out of the scenery.

The song needs none of that.

It works because sooner or later most of us have looked around at our lives and wondered, in one form or another:

How did I get here?

And is this where I meant to go?

I hadn’t heard the song, as far as I can remember, in decades.

Yet there it was when I woke up this morning, already playing somewhere in my cerebral cortex. Apparently my brain had filed it away sometime around 1967 or 1968 and decided, nearly sixty years later, that today would be a good day to take it off the shelf.

Brains are peculiar things.

Earworms are even more peculiar.

But every once in a while, you get a good one.

Thoughts While Sitting at the 2025 World Science Fiction Convention in Seattle.

Sitting in the dealers’ room at the 2025 World Science Fiction Convention (WorldCon) in Seattle. Wearing my replica TNG-era com badge and Starfleet delta earrings. I didn’t wear my Manticoran Navy officer’s uniform because my involvement in the TRMN has waned significantly. A gentleman sitting at the same table is wearing his uniform, and I said, “Go Manticore!”, but he ignored me.

My publisher threatened to take away my author card if I didn’t autograph copies of my books at his table. So, if you want some autographed books, you can head over to Water Dragon Publishing, or, better yet, send me an email and I’ll be happy to address an autograph to you personally.

The first ribbon I attached to my member badge says, “No Kings.” I picked it up at the registration desk before I even obtained my dealer badge (ribbon). Dozens of people have asked me where I got it, and when I tell them, they respond, “There weren’t any there when I went through registration.”

Sorry, dude. Can’t help you with that. I haven’t seen many No Kings ribbons, so I’m thinking they may have been a limited run.

I’m not seeing many panels on today’s schedule that I want to attend, but there is one at 19:30 tonight that looks interesting:

Why Does the Alt-Right Love Science Fiction?

The description: Over the past few decades, there have been attempts to co-opt science fiction in support of racist, sexist, and classist political movements. Even works such as Star Trek, Neuromancer, and The Dispossessed have been claimed by alt-right leaders as foundational texts for their awful worldviews. Why does the alt-right love science fiction, and what problematic assumptions are coded into the genre that cause it to be open to these interpretations?

First off, anyone who wonders, “When did Star Trek become so woke?” has had their head up their butt since 1966. 

Second, I’m well aware that embracing science fiction fandom has placed me solidly in a progressive echo chamber. If the bulk of Sci-Fi fans had their druthers, The Felon and his cronies, along with all the White Christian Nationalists, would have been launched into a parallel universe long ago, where they can play out their Project 2025-basedmasturbatory fantasies without bothering other people.

That’s not to say that there aren’t any Republicans at the Con today, but they tend to keep their political opinions to themselves and quietly back out of conversations that turn political. And they tend to be the kind of Republican who’d vote for Eisenhower or Nixon, but not The Felon.

Thirdly, I have a dinner engagement tonight, but if I can get back to the Con before 19:30, I’ll attend this panel.

What do I do about the echo chamber? Truthfully, not much. I remind myself that the loudest progressives are just as guilty of not fact-checking their talking points as Fox News is. I mean, really, people just don’t google it when it supports their agenda. 

Apropos of nothing, here is a Hawaiian Dalek.

The Constitutional Convention – Andrea argues with her characters.

Some background: I meet with a writers’ critique group every Friday, where we read our WIPs to each other and get instant feedback. I’m going to read this to the group this Friday. Of course, by commenting on the piece, they become part of the story.

The Constitutional Convention

A Meta Story about the Republic of Kentaurus

By Andrea Monticue

It was a cold, gray, rainy April morning in Monmouth, Oregon, and my Invicta Dive Watch indicated that it was still five minutes before the meeting started. I had the meeting invitation in my daypack, but I knew it by heart: Organizational Meeting. Noon. Public Library. Topic: What the hell, sistah? Bring your laptop. Other participants: Your literary creations.

This was not the first time my “literary creations” had forced a meeting of the minds on me. Usually, they didn’t bother with an invitation to a meeting – they just showed up at my office, helping themselves to my coffee, carrying a handwritten list of grievances. This always annoyed me, considering the advanced technology I’ve bequeathed to them. They have starships that travel at many multiples of the speed of light, for crying out loud! Can’t they invest in one measly iPad?

I walked into the library meeting room expecting to see the usual suspects and I was surprised to see some additional faces. 

Bear stood near the door dressed in his medical corpsman uniform. He presented himself standing at a full seven feet tall, his tongue lolling over his wolfish teeth and his tail wagging to indicate pleasure at seeing me, greeted me at the door, and handed me a complimentary pair of smartglasses. 

“Thank you, Bear! You’re always so thoughtful.” I was pleased that it was the better iGlasses from Apple and not the minimalist Google Viewer. Bear wasn’t able to reproduce human vocalizations, so he needed the translating ability of the smartglasses to participate. Everyone in the room was wearing them. This was good because, with the exception of Sharon Manders, the former UC Santa Cruz anthropology professor sitting at the podium on a stool, I was the only one there who spoke 21st-century English.

I set my daypack down on the nearest chair and donned the smartglasses while Sharon talked. “Thank you for showing up on time, Andrea.”

I gave her the finger then looked around the room. Teagan Wough with their unreadable mien, and Etta Place, dressed in a cowboy hat, tee shirt and jeans, were sitting to one side. Xoanna Campoverde, the Minister of the Navy on Kentaurus, and Elrydien Daerîsiell, the Elf who did Campoverde’s dirty, often extrajudicial work, sat next to each other opposite from Teagan and Etta. They both had their arms crossed in silent defiance.

The biggest surprise was Senator Robert Schoonover from the Annermani Province of Kentaurus, currently chairing the Senate Intelligence Oversight Committee.  Despite his position, he wore casual slacks and a plaid vest over a simple cotton shirt. 

“Bob,” I said, giving him a nod. “Always good to see you.” I greeted the rest with a glance and gritted teeth.

“Hey, boss,” he reflected and smiled. It’s always nice to have one’s fictional characters acknowledge who’s in charge, though I wondered if Bob was just being ingratiating. 

The room was designed for business meetings with tables and hard chairs, an acoustic drop ceiling, and large windows facing the parking lot. Rain battered against the glass, causing a distraction.

Refusing to take a seat, I looked Sharon in the eyes and said, “Okay. What’s the deal? What are you pissed about now? You called this meeting, I’m sure.”

“Don’t get your dander up, Writer,” she said, raising a placating hand. “We actually think you’re doing a bang-up job on your current projects. We just feel that something is lacking.”

“Lacking?” I raised my voice louder than I intended to. “Lacking? Do you understand how many nights I lie sleepless in bed, thinking about the details of your universe?”

“C’mon, boss, that’s not fair,” Bob interjected. He was wearing that smiling politician’s face, designed to deescalate tensions among his constituents. “We’re not saying that world-building is easy or that you’re giving less than your all. Just hear us out, okay?”

“Yes, madam universe creator,” Xoanna said. Did she have the world’s sexiest accent or what? It made her sarcasm easier to swallow. “We merely want to point out a foundational lapse.”

“If I may,” Teagan interrupted. “Let me give you a scenario: The first paragraph of your first book mentions a ship traveling in space. This ship cannot just pop into existence without people to build it. And people infer a society with its attendant laws. But what are these laws?”

“I, uh, I’ve been creating them as necessary,” I offered.

“Yes, but is that fair?” Teagan said. “Especially since a solid hunk of the story takes place in a government setting.”

“Exactly,” Bob said. “How am I supposed to be a senator when I don’t know how the role is defined? What authority does my committee have? How was I elected, and who elected me?”

“The citizens, of course!” I said, feeling like I was pointing out the obvious.

“But what’s a citizen?” Xoanna asked. “Shouldn’t this be defined somewhere? And is it a direct vote, or do they choose their electors?”

I admitted internally that they had a point. “You’re asking me how the government is run. What its constitution is. That’s like asking me how the FTL engines work. I have no clue!”

“I’d like to point out that that isn’t entirely true,” Elrydien spoke for the first time. Everybody turned to look at her. “You have an education in physics, and you like to stay current on physics research. You’ve made an effort to incorporate this into the story without getting bogged down in details.”

“Yeah, that’s a good cure for insomnia,” I said.

“But look at the work you’ve done behind the scenes,” she continued. “You have literally pages of spreadsheets detailing stellar distances and how long it takes to travel between them. You’ve written detailed specifications on different models of starship engines. Your readers never see this stuff.”

“Almost sounds obsessive to me,” Bob said, smiling. If he was trying to disarm my defensiveness, he wasn’t doing the best job.

“You need a constitution,” Xoanna said. 

I thought about all the work that goes into writing a modern constitution and nearly collapsed in imaginary exhaustion.

“Nobody has to see it,” Bob said. “But it will keep our interactions consistent, and you won’t have annoyed readers sending you emails, saying, ‘In your first book, you said that the Kentauran parliament is unicameral and consisted of representatives, but in the second book, you introduce Bob as a Senator.’”

“Good point,” Sharon said.

Shit. And Bob didn’t know the half of it.

“Is that what this is all about? Okay, you’re a representative.”

“That’s not the point!” Bob objected.

“Okay, I’ll retcon the parliament as bicameral.”

Bob blew air from puffed cheeks in frustration. “Look, I don’t care. You just need to be consistent, or fans will eat you up.”

“And you can work on it when you have to take a break from your WIPs,” Etta jumped in, referring to Works in Progress. “It’s not like there’s a f’king hurry. The only lives on the line are the ones in your overactive imagination.” I could tell she was actively trying to curb her sailor’s mouth.

“If I may,” Teagan interrupted. “I don’t know anybody who’s written a constitution for a space-faring society before. Although, it wouldn’t surprise me if David Weber has. You can take all those musty, centuries-old Earth constitutions and give them a post-modern twist. What other nascent nations have had to worry about multiple species, genetic manipulations, robots, and interstellar treaties?”

“I’m not a lawyer,” I said defensively. “And I’m not a politician, or a philosopher, or any of those things one needs to be to write a constitution.”

“You’re also not a starship captain,” Etta offered. “You’re also not a spy, or a sailor, or a combat aviator, or a quantum electrician, or a diplomat, or a roboticist, or an information specialist, or an anthropologist, or a —“

“Etta, enough,” Bear calmly interrupted with his synthesized voice that sounded like Laurence Fishburne. 

“Oh, you get the idea. You’re none of these things that you write about.”

“It’s not just that,” I said apologetically. “You can’t write a constitution with just one voice. You need a chorus. It requires a meeting of the finest minds of that society. Otherwise, you risk expressing only a single ideology.”

“We can contribute,” Sharon offered.

“All of you,” I said, indicating the entire group with a gesture, “are me.” 

“I do hope you don’t believe that you and I share ideals of what a government is supposed to do,” Xoanna said, sitting up straight, ready for a fight, looking as if she’d just been insulted. 

“You can always take it to that critique group that meets on Fridays,” Bear said. “They certainly have a variety of opinions, more or less valid.”

I cringed. I could already hear the group’s questions and objections.